Failed Perc Test Lots: Sundrive Biovaporator or NextGen Septic?

I invest in vacant land in Pennsylvania, and several of my lots have failed the perc test because of a high seasonal water table. On the most recent one, the soil boring showed mottling right up to the surface. Sand mounds, drip and other soil-based alternatives need at least 20 inches of usable soil, so they’re out.

I’m now exploring systems that don’t put any water into the ground at all, and I’ve found two:

Sundrive Biovaporator: a lined, insulated solar greenhouse where the wastewater is eliminated through evaporation and plant transpiration. It is on PA DEP’s list of approved alternate systems, and DEP’s listing specifically mentions sites with a shallow seasonal high water table. It typically needs about an acre, and it comes with real upkeep: monthly checks, cover crops to mow and replant, and new greenhouse film every few years.

NextGen Septic Zero Liquid Discharge: the wastewater is treated and then sprayed into the air as a fine mist from a unit about 4 x 4 feet. Arizona exempted one installation from its groundwater permit, and the company says it is approved in Kentucky and South Dakota. It is not approved in Pennsylvania. I don’t know whether NextGen has ever applied here, or if it did, what stopped it.

Has anyone installed, owned, sold or bought a property with either system? I’d especially like to hear about:

  • what it cost to install and what it costs to maintain,
  • how it holds up in Northeast winters and humid weather,
  • whether it affected resale value or buyer interest,
  • any experience getting a sewage enforcement officer or DEP to sign off.

Any pros and cons you’ve seen firsthand would be a big help. Thanks in advance.

Very interesting. I didn’t realize there was a septic system that wouldn’t put ANY water into the ground at all. Sounds complicated or expensive, or both… but again, I haven’t seen either of these before.

You could always try reaching out to Mitch Klein about this. He’s the best expert that comes to mind on the subject. I interviewed him here in this podcast episode.